Baseball Challenge Coins

Baseball challenge coins are highly collectible items that serve as enduring mementos, commemorating a player’s accomplishments, a team’s rich history, or significant moments within the game. These unique tokens are meticulously crafted from various metals, including brass, copper, or nickel, and typically sport round or oval shapes. They offer ample opportunities for customization, featuring team logos, player names, or heartfelt messages.

In addition to the classic designs, baseball challenge coins may showcase various elements such as baseball bats, gloves, or the iconic baseball diamond, often imbued with a distinct, currency-like value. With the expertise of a skilled Challenge Coin Maker elevating their craftsmanship.

Baseball Challenge Coins Pricing

5 25 50 100 150 200 250 300 Mold Fee
1.5" $15.5 $9.18 $5.56 $3.48 $3.43 $3.21 $3.17 $2.94 $90
1.75" $15.5 $10.13 $6.10 $3.95 $3.90 $3.77 $3.73 $3.39 $115
2" $16.5 $10.58 $6.38 $4.31 $4.26 $4.13 $4.09 $3.85 $140
2.25" $16.5 $12.08 $7.25 $4.87 $4.80 $4.71 $4.66 $4.34 $165
2.5" $17.5 $14.81 $8.86 $5.66 $5.62 $5.46 $5.41 $5.17 $190

Custom Challenge Coin Plating Options

Custom coin plating is a process of applying a layer of metal coating onto a coin or medal to enhance its appearance, durability, and value. This technique involves electroplating a thin layer of gold, silver, copper, or other precious metals onto the surface of the coin to create a unique design and color. 

Shiny Gold
Shiny Silver
Shiny Copper
Antique Gold
Antique Silver
Antique Copper-Plating
Antique Copper
Antique Brass
Matt Gold
Dual Plating

Custom Challenge Coin Process

Custom coin coloring is a process of adding color to a coin or medal to create a unique and personalized design. This technique involves using special paints, enamels, or inks to add color to specific areas of the coin, such as the text, image, or border. The coloring process involves several steps, including applying a base coat, adding the desired colors, and finishing with a protective layer. The result is a vibrant and eye-catching coin that is both attractive and valuable.


Die-Struck Coin
Enamel Coin
printing Coin
3D coin
Curve Coin
Commemorative Coin
Glow In Dark Coin
Glow In Dark Coin
Glitter Coin

Custom Challenge Coin Edge Options

Custom coin edge refers to the raised or recessed outer edge of a coin that surrounds the main design. This area is often used to add text, numbers, or other decorative elements that enhance the overall appearance of the coin. Custom coin edges can be plain, reeded, or decorated with various patterns or designs. They can also include a smooth or serrated texture, or be shaped in a unique way to match the theme or purpose of the coin.

Standard Edge

Standard Edge

Rope Edge

Rope Edge

Chain Edge

Chain Edge

Reeded Edge

Reeded Edge

Engraving Edge

Engraving Edge

Spur Edge

Spur Edge

Bevel Edge

Bevel Edge

Cross Cut Edge

Cross Cut Edge

Diamond Edge

Diamond Edge

Packaging Options

Presentation options refer to the various ways in which custom coins, medals, and other commemorative items can be displayed or packaged. These options can include custom packaging such as velvet boxes, wooden or acrylic displays, or custom inserts to hold the item in place. Presentation options can also include accessories such as lanyards, keychains, or lapel pins that complement the design of the coin or medal.

PVC Pouch

PVC Pouch

Round plastic case

Round Plastic Case

Velvet Case

Velvet Case


Black Plastic Holder

Rectangular plastic case

Rectangular plastic case


Wooden Holder

Custom Pantone Colors


Since different monitors and screens show colors in different ways, we use Pantone colors to show colors. These are industry standards that don’t change depending on the screen.

The classic style of custom challenge coins gives them a formal look that works for any event or occasion. Add color to your design, especially for corporate coins, if you want it to stand out even more. We don’t charge extra for up to five different colors.

Not sure what color you want exactly? Just name a professional or college sports team or a Fortune 500 company that uses a color you like, and we can look up the Pantone color for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

A1: Challenge coins are small metal coins or medallions that often have a design or emblem on one or both sides. They are typically given to members of a particular organization or group to commemorate an event or achievement and may also serve as a symbol of membership or camaraderie.

A2: The origins of custom challenge coins are somewhat disputed, but they are believed to have originated in the military. The tradition of carrying a challenge coin as a symbol of affiliation and camaraderie dates back at least to World War I.

A3: Custom challenge coins are often used to recognize and reward members of an organization or group for their service or achievements. They may also serve as a way to build camaraderie and team spirit.

A4: Custom challenge coins are typically given to members of a particular organization or group, such as military units, law enforcement agencies, or fire departments. They may also be given to members of a corporate team or other professional group.

A5: In the military, custom challenge coins may be given to recognize a soldier’s service, as a token of appreciation, or as a way to build morale and camaraderie within a unit. They may also be used in informal challenges or games, where the person who does not have their coin on them must buy a round of drinks.

A6: Yes, anyone can design and manufacture a challenge coin. However, custom challenge coins are most commonly created for specific organizations or groups and are often customized with the organization’s emblem or logo.

A7: Custom challenge coins can be made from a variety of materials, including brass, copper, nickel, zinc, and even precious metals like gold or silver. They may also be coated with a protective finish to prevent tarnishing or damage.


Although creating challenge coins is a lot of fun, there are many considerations to make beforehand. Fortunately, we’ve made bespoke coins for many years, and we’re pleased to assist you at every stage.

You can find all the information you want regarding custom challenge coin design in our how-to guide.

Blog: How To Design A Challenge Coin?

A9: While challenge coins are often given as a gift or token of appreciation, they may also be sold or traded among collectors. Some rare or highly sought-after custom challenge coins can be quite valuable to collectors. However, it is important to note that the resale of challenge coins may be restricted by the organization or group that issued them.

A10: No, while custom challenge coins are most commonly associated with the military, they are also used in other organizations and groups, such as law enforcement agencies, fire departments, corporate teams, and even social clubs.

History of Baseball Challenge Coins

The tradition of utilizing custom challenge coins to honor achievements in baseball dates back to the early 1900s. During this era, baseball teams and players frequently employed these distinctive tokens to immortalize their victories, championships, and notable accomplishments. These coins were typically crafted from metal and adorned with the team or player’s logo or emblem on one side, while the reverse side often featured a special message or phrase. Custom challenge coins played a pivotal role in acknowledging the remarkable feats of individual players or entire teams.

In contemporary times, baseball custom challenge coins continue to serve as cherished memorabilia for celebrating victories and championships. Most baseball teams now have their own meticulously designed custom challenge coins, proudly showcasing the team’s distinctive logo or emblem.

Symbolism of Baseball Challenge Coins

Baseball challenge coins are more than just a physical item; they are also a symbolic representation of a team or player’s accomplishments. The coins often feature the team’s logo or insignia, as well as a special message or phrase. This message can be used to express appreciation to a particular player or team, or to honor a special event or accomplishment.

The Baseball Challenge Coins also serve as a reminder of the hard work and dedication it takes to achieve success in the game of baseball. When presented to an individual or team, the coins can be used to show respect and appreciation for their accomplishments.

How do you make a Baseball Challenge Coin?

Crafting a Baseball Challenge Coin involves a straightforward process. Initially, you’ll need to determine the design, which typically encompasses the team’s logo, name, and a unique team-related phrase or slogan. Once your design is finalized, the next step is selecting the metal for the coin. Popular metal choices include brass, bronze, nickel, gold, and silver. With the metal chosen, it’s time to entrust the creation of your Sports Coins to a skilled and experienced challenge coin maker. These professionals utilize specialized tools and techniques to bring your coin design to life.

The Value of Little League Baseball Medals

Little League Baseball is one of the most beloved sports in the United States, and it has been around for decades. Each year, thousands of kids don their uniforms and take to the field to compete in Little League Baseball tournaments. At the end of the tournament, teams are awarded medals to recognize their hard work and dedication. Little League Baseball medals are a great way to reward players for their efforts and are a symbol of pride for the players and their team.

Little League Baseball medals not only reward the players for their efforts, but also serve as a memento of their time in Little League Baseball. These medals are a great way to commemorate a successful season, and for most players, it is a reminder of their hard work and dedication to the sport. Medals also serve as a symbol of the team’s unity, as it is a physical manifestation of the bond between the players and coaches.

How do you make a Baseball Challenge Coin?

There are many different challenges in a game of baseball, including hitting, pitching, fielding, baserunning, and strategy. Hitting is the most important challenge as it is the primary way to score runs and win games. Pitching is the next most important challenge, as the pitcher must be able to throw the ball accurately and effectively to get the opposing team out. 

Fielding is also an important challenge, as the players must be able to catch the ball and make accurate throws to the bases. Baserunning is the challenge of running the bases efficiently and with proper timing, as it is essential for scoring runs. Strategy is also an important challenge, as the manager must be able to make the right decisions in order to win the game.

Creating Your Own Baseball Team

Creating your own baseball team can be a fun and rewarding experience. Whether it’s a team to compete in local leagues or just a pick-up game with friends, having your own team is a great way to enjoy the sport. Here are some tips for forming and managing your own team.

The first step to creating your own team is to find players. Start by finding a few friends who are interested in playing, then look for players in your local area.

Once you have a team, it’s time to organize the team. Decide on the team name, logo, and uniform, and create a schedule of practices and games. You will also need to decide on a set of rules and regulations that everyone must follow.

Creating your own baseball team can be a great way to get involved in the sport and to have some fun with friends. With some dedication and organization, you can have a successful and enjoyable experience.

Can civilians have challenge coins?

Challenge coins are not exclusive to military units, law enforcement agencies, and government organizations; they are also embraced by a diverse array of civilian entities, including businesses, charities, and social clubs.

Many civilian organizations go a step further by crafting custom challenge coins tailored for civilian recipients. These unique challenge coins are specially designed to honor individuals who have extended their support to a specific charity or volunteered their time and efforts for a community project. In such instances, the challenge coin serves as a tangible emblem, symbolizing the recipient’s unwavering commitment and dedication to a particular cause or organization, often finding a prominent place in the challenge coin gallery of cherished mementos.

What does it mean to be gifted a challenge coin?

Being gifted a challenge coin is often seen as a sign of recognition and appreciation for one’s service or accomplishments within a particular organization or community. The giving of a challenge coin is often associated with the military, but it is also common in other groups such as law enforcement, firefighting, and other public service organizations.

The specific meaning of being gifted a challenge coin can vary depending on the organization or group involved. In some cases, it may simply be a token of appreciation or a way to commemorate a particular event or achievement. In other cases, it may be a way of showing respect or solidarity among members of a particular organization.

Blogs - Related Posts
Wedding Challenge Coin
What Is Wedding Coins

The newly engaged couples organize the ceremony, guest list, and wedding favors. Our custom wedding coins create special gifts for guests.

Read More »
Motorcycle Coins -2
What Is Police Motorcycle Challenge Coin

With Super ChallengeCoins, you can design your own motorcycle police challenge coins. Allow us to assist you with your police motorcycle coins now that we’ve worked with various police departments.

Read More »
Are You Ready to Custom Challenge Coins?​
Free Quote-2

Free quote now