Rare Challenge Coins

Custom Challenge Coins that are considered rare often boast distinctive designs and features that set them apart from their counterparts.

For instance, these unique Challenge Coins may take on special shapes, such as shields or pentagons, and they might be crafted from unusual materials like gold or silver.

Rare Challenge Coins hold a particular allure as they represent a unique piece of history that can be cherished and passed down through generations or collected as a cherished hobby.

Rare Challenge Coins Pricing

5 25 50 100 150 200 250 300 Mold Fee
1.5" $15.5 $9.18 $5.56 $3.48 $3.43 $3.21 $3.17 $2.94 $90
1.75" $15.5 $10.13 $6.10 $3.95 $3.90 $3.77 $3.73 $3.39 $115
2" $16.5 $10.58 $6.38 $4.31 $4.26 $4.13 $4.09 $3.85 $140
2.25" $16.5 $12.08 $7.25 $4.87 $4.80 $4.71 $4.66 $4.34 $165
2.5" $17.5 $14.81 $8.86 $5.66 $5.62 $5.46 $5.41 $5.17 $190

Custom Challenge Coin Plating Options

Custom coin plating is a process of applying a layer of metal coating onto a coin or medal to enhance its appearance, durability, and value. This technique involves electroplating a thin layer of gold, silver, copper, or other precious metals onto the surface of the coin to create a unique design and color. 

Shiny Gold
Shiny Silver
Shiny Copper
Antique Gold
Antique Silver
Antique Copper-Plating
Antique Copper
Antique Brass
Matt Gold
Dual Plating

Custom Challenge Coin Process

Custom coin coloring is a process of adding color to a coin or medal to create a unique and personalized design. This technique involves using special paints, enamels, or inks to add color to specific areas of the coin, such as the text, image, or border. The coloring process involves several steps, including applying a base coat, adding the desired colors, and finishing with a protective layer. The result is a vibrant and eye-catching coin that is both attractive and valuable.


Die-Struck Coin
Enamel Coin
printing Coin
3D coin
Curve Coin
Commemorative Coin
Glow In Dark Coin
Glow In Dark Coin
Glitter Coin

Custom Challenge Coin Edge Options

Custom coin edge refers to the raised or recessed outer edge of a coin that surrounds the main design. This area is often used to add text, numbers, or other decorative elements that enhance the overall appearance of the coin. Custom coin edges can be plain, reeded, or decorated with various patterns or designs. They can also include a smooth or serrated texture, or be shaped in a unique way to match the theme or purpose of the coin.

Standard Edge

Standard Edge

Rope Edge

Rope Edge

Chain Edge

Chain Edge

Reeded Edge

Reeded Edge

Engraving Edge

Engraving Edge

Spur Edge

Spur Edge

Bevel Edge

Bevel Edge

Cross Cut Edge

Cross Cut Edge

Diamond Edge

Diamond Edge

Packaging Options

Presentation options refer to the various ways in which custom coins, medals, and other commemorative items can be displayed or packaged. These options can include custom packaging such as velvet boxes, wooden or acrylic displays, or custom inserts to hold the item in place. Presentation options can also include accessories such as lanyards, keychains, or lapel pins that complement the design of the coin or medal.

PVC Pouch

PVC Pouch

Round plastic case

Round Plastic Case

Velvet Case

Velvet Case


Black Plastic Holder

Rectangular plastic case

Rectangular plastic case


Wooden Holder

Custom Pantone Colors


Since different monitors and screens show colors in different ways, we use Pantone colors to show colors. These are industry standards that don’t change depending on the screen.

The classic style of custom challenge coins gives them a formal look that works for any event or occasion. Add color to your design, especially for corporate coins, if you want it to stand out even more. We don’t charge extra for up to five different colors.

Not sure what color you want exactly? Just name a professional or college sports team or a Fortune 500 company that uses a color you like, and we can look up the Pantone color for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

A1: Challenge coins are small metal coins or medallions that often have a design or emblem on one or both sides. They are typically given to members of a particular organization or group to commemorate an event or achievement and may also serve as a symbol of membership or camaraderie.

A2: The origins of custom challenge coins are somewhat disputed, but they are believed to have originated in the military. The tradition of carrying a challenge coin as a symbol of affiliation and camaraderie dates back at least to World War I.

A3: Custom challenge coins are often used to recognize and reward members of an organization or group for their service or achievements. They may also serve as a way to build camaraderie and team spirit.

A4: Custom challenge coins are typically given to members of a particular organization or group, such as military units, law enforcement agencies, or fire departments. They may also be given to members of a corporate team or other professional group.

A5: In the military, custom challenge coins may be given to recognize a soldier’s service, as a token of appreciation, or as a way to build morale and camaraderie within a unit. They may also be used in informal challenges or games, where the person who does not have their coin on them must buy a round of drinks.

A6: Yes, anyone can design and manufacture a challenge coin. However, custom challenge coins are most commonly created for specific organizations or groups and are often customized with the organization’s emblem or logo.

A7: Custom challenge coins can be made from a variety of materials, including brass, copper, nickel, zinc, and even precious metals like gold or silver. They may also be coated with a protective finish to prevent tarnishing or damage.


Although creating challenge coins is a lot of fun, there are many considerations to make beforehand. Fortunately, we’ve made bespoke coins for many years, and we’re pleased to assist you at every stage.

You can find all the information you want regarding custom challenge coin design in our how-to guide.

Blog: How To Design A Challenge Coin?

A9: While challenge coins are often given as a gift or token of appreciation, they may also be sold or traded among collectors. Some rare or highly sought-after custom challenge coins can be quite valuable to collectors. However, it is important to note that the resale of challenge coins may be restricted by the organization or group that issued them.

A10: No, while custom challenge coins are most commonly associated with the military, they are also used in other organizations and groups, such as law enforcement agencies, fire departments, corporate teams, and even social clubs.

What Makes a Challenge Coin Rare?

Several factors can influence the rarity of a challenge coin, with one of the most prominent being the production quantity. If a specific coin was custom challenge coins produced in limited numbers, it is likely to be considered rare and hold greater value.

Furthermore, the significance of the coin itself can also contribute to its rarity. Coins created to commemorate significant events or to honor specific individuals are typically more valuable than those produced for routine purposes.

Lastly, the coin’s condition plays a crucial role. Challenge coins custom made in pristine condition, with no signs of wear or damage, command higher value than those that have been circulated or show signs of wear and tear.

Rare Navy Challenge Coins

The United States Navy boasts a rich history of military challenge coins, and collectors often covet many of these coins. Among the most sought-after navy challenge coins are the SEAL Team 6 Red Squadron coin, the USS Indianapolis coin, and the USS Nimitz coin.

The SEAL Team 6 Red Squadron coin is an exceptionally rare gem among navy challenge coins. It was minted in honor of the elite Navy SEAL team that executed the mission to capture Osama bin Laden. With only a limited production, these coins have become highly sought after by collectors.

Another among the rarest navy challenge coins is the USS Indianapolis coin. This coin serves as a poignant tribute to the USS Indianapolis, which tragically sank during World War II after being torpedoed by a Japanese submarine. Only a handful of the crew survived, making this coin a precious and historically significant piece.

Similarly, the USS Nimitz coin ranks among the rare navy challenge coins. It commemorates the commissioning of the USS Nimitz, one of the world’s largest and most formidable aircraft carriers.

Some examples of particularly rare or valuable challenge coins that have been sold at auction in recent years

Some of the most valuable challenge coins sold at auction in recent years include a 1913 US Army Officer’s Mess President Taft inaugural coin that sold for $35,250, a 1943 Pappy Boyington Flying Tigers coin that fetched $55,000, and a 2007 Special Forces Night Stalkers coin that sold for $37,500.

How do military units and other organizations go about creating custom challenge coins, and what factors influence the rarity and value of these coins?

Custom military challenge coins are often crafted in collaboration with a challenge coin maker to design and manufacture these unique tokens. Their rarity and value are shaped by a variety of factors, encompassing their design, production quantities, historical importance, and overall condition. For inspiration and design options, explore our challenge coin gallery.

Why are some rare military challenge coins more rare than others?

Military challenge coins may be rare because they were only distributed to a select group of individuals or were produced in limited quantities. Additionally, coins associated with important historical events or military units may be more sought after by collectors.

What are some popular themes for rare challenge coins?

Military units and branches, historic events, law enforcement agencies, and political campaigns are all popular themes for rare challenge coins.

Are you supposed to buy challenge coins?

Challenge coins are typically given as a token of appreciation, recognition, or belonging to a certain group or organization. They are not typically sold to the general public but rather distributed to members of the group or organization.

However, some challenge coins may be available for purchase from some challenge coins manufacturer.

If you are interested in purchasing a challenge coin, you may want to research the specific coin or organization to learn more about its history and significance. It’s important to note that while challenge coins may have monetary value as collectibles, their true value lies in their symbolic meaning and the experiences and memories they represent.

What do you do when you get a challenge coin?

Traditionally, receiving a challenge coin is considered an honor and a sign of respect in many organizations, particularly in the military. If you receive a challenge coin, it is customary to carry it with you at all times, as a symbol of pride and belonging to the organization that awarded it to you.

Some people display them in a collection, while others keep them in a special place as a personal memento. Whatever you choose to do, the important thing is to appreciate the significance of the coin and the recognition that it represents.

Blogs - Related Posts
Wedding Challenge Coin
What Is Wedding Coins

The newly engaged couples organize the ceremony, guest list, and wedding favors. Our custom wedding coins create special gifts for guests.

Read More »
Motorcycle Coins -2
What Is Police Motorcycle Challenge Coin

With Super ChallengeCoins, you can design your own motorcycle police challenge coins. Allow us to assist you with your police motorcycle coins now that we’ve worked with various police departments.

Read More »
Are You Ready to Custom Challenge Coins?
Free Quote-2

Free quote now